Music

The Story Behind My Signed Tool Poster

Written By: Andrew Siemon


Every guitarist has that one piece of memorabilia that means more than its price tag – something that reminds you why you started playing in the first place. For me, that’s a signed Tool poster I picked up over a decade ago at a show in Toronto.

This isn’t a review of a pedal or an amp. It’s a look at a different kind of “gear”: the kind that lives on your wall, shapes your musical identity, and quietly pushes you to play better every time you glance at it.


Overview / First Impressions

I grabbed this Tool poster about 12 years ago at the Air Canada Centre in Toronto. It was one of those impulse decisions at the merch table that turned out to be absolutely worth it.

  • Band: Tool
  • Location: Air Canada Centre, Toronto
  • Approx. price at the time: Around $100
  • Signatures: Maynard James Keenan, Justin Chancellor, and at least one other member (the third signature isn’t 100% clear)

From a distance, it just looks like a sharp, well-designed piece of band art. Up close, you see the signatures, and that’s when it becomes something special.

It’s not just a poster you bought online – it’s tied to a specific night, a specific show, and a specific moment in your life as a fan and musician.


Build Quality & Design

Posters aren’t “built” like guitars, but how you present and protect them matters.

  • Framing: I had it put in a solid, high-quality frame, which instantly elevated it from “cool merch” to “wall centerpiece.”
  • Protection: The frame keeps it flat, clean, and safe from dust, sunlight, and accidental damage.
  • Visual impact: Between the artwork and the visible signatures, it has the look of a serious collector’s piece rather than a random bedroom poster.

From a guitarist’s perspective, this is the kind of thing you want in your practice space or studio – something that looks pro and feels inspiring.


Features & Functions (Yes, Even a Poster Has Some)

While it’s not a piece of audio gear, this poster still “does” something important:

  • Autographs: Maynard’s signature is clearly visible, Justin Chancellor’s appears to be there, and there’s a third signature that’s a bit harder to identify. Even if it’s not every member of the band, having multiple signatures gives it real collector value.
  • Authenticity: It was bought directly at the show, not second-hand, which adds a layer of confidence and personal connection.
  • Display value: The combination of art, signatures, and framing makes it a strong visual focal point in any music room.

Think of it as a permanent, silent reminder of one of the bands that helped define modern heavy, progressive guitar music.


How It Inspires a Guitarist

Tool isn’t just another rock band – they’re a reference point for guitarists who care about:

  • Odd time signatures
  • Textured, layered tones
  • Riffs that evolve rather than just repeat
  • The interplay between bass, drums, and guitar

Having this poster on the wall does a few things for me as a player:

  • Motivation: On days when picking up the guitar feels like work, seeing that poster pulls me back into the mindset of being a fan first.
  • Connection to a moment: I remember the sound of that show, the tones, the dynamics, and it nudges me to chase that level of intensity in my own playing.
  • Identity: It quietly says, “This is the kind of music that matters to me,” which shapes the kind of riffs and ideas I naturally gravitate toward.

It’s amazing how a simple piece of signed paper can influence your creative headspace more than another plugin or pedal sometimes.


Limitations / Things to Know

There are a few practical realities with something like this:

  • Unclear signatures: I’m certain about Maynard and pretty sure about Justin Chancellor, but one of the signatures is harder to identify. If you’re a serious collector, that kind of ambiguity might matter.
  • Not every member (probably): It doesn’t appear to be signed by all four members, so it’s not a “complete band” piece in the strictest sense.
  • Value vs. cost: It was around $100 at the time, plus the cost of a solid frame. Whether that’s “worth it” financially is debatable, but emotionally and artistically, it’s been a great investment.

If you’re considering picking up similar memorabilia at shows, it’s worth going in knowing that not every “signed” item will be perfectly documented or complete – but the personal value can still be huge.


Final Thoughts

This Tool poster isn’t a pedal, an amp, or a guitar – but it’s absolutely part of my rig.

It lives in a good frame, hangs where I can see it, and reminds me of a specific night, a specific band, and a specific standard of musicianship. For around $100 and a bit of framing, I ended up with a piece I’m genuinely proud of and still glad I grabbed all these years later.

If you’re a guitarist and a fan of a particular band, don’t underestimate how powerful a piece of signed art or memorabilia can be in your space. It won’t change your tone, but it might change the way you feel when you plug in – and sometimes that’s the most important upgrade of all.

Leave a Comment

Hey — I’m Andrew Siemon, the creator behind Andrew Reviews Everything. I’ve been a guitarist for years, and along the way I’ve gone deep into the world of music gear, recording, and production — not just the fun creative side, but the real-world side too: what gear is actually worth buying, what’s overrated, and what’s just marketing.